Talking about medical liability in pregnancy and childbirth requires looking beyond clinical lex artis: the Council of State has just set a precedent linking obstetric negligence to gender-based violence. In a ruling dated July 9, 2026 (case number 05001-23-33-000-2020-03945-01, docket 72.435), the Third Section, Subsection A, with Justice José Roberto Sáchica Méndezas rapporteur, upheld the conviction against two healthcare providers in Antioquia for the death of a 27-year-old woman, 37 weeks pregnant, who did not receive timely care in response to warning signs of severe preeclampsia.
The facts of the case
Natalia Andrea Restrepo Tamayo sought care on June 29, 2018 at the healthcare provider Sumimedical for severe headache and dark urine, and received outpatient care. The next day she was seen at Hospital Santa Margarita de Copacabana, where she was likewise discharged without being admitted. She returned on July 2 and was referred to Hospital General de Medellín, where she was diagnosed with severe preeclampsia, HELLP syndrome, and acute fatty liver of pregnancy. She died on July 8, 2018, and no autopsy was performed.
The gender perspective: when obstetric negligence amounts to obstetric violence
One of the central points of the ruling is that deficient care during pregnancy and childbirth "cannot be analyzed under the traditional rules" of medical liability. The Chamber warned that this type of negligence "can be classified as a form" of obstetric violence, and stressed that "the gender perspective is not a rhetorical statement": it must translate into the concrete way in which the judge weighs the evidence and understands the facts.
The standard of medical liability applied by the Chamber
The Council of State reiterated that, in matters of medical liability, "a mere culpa in abstracto is insufficient to hold a healthcare professional liable": the failure must be proven concretely, and the harm "does not admit a legal presumption and must be alleged and proven". In this case, an expert opinion from a gynecologist established that Sumimedical failed to assess the warning signs (headache and dark urine), did not perform a complete examination or order timely laboratory tests, and did not refer the patient to a higher level of care. On causation, the Chamber applied the criterion of "the factual cause — conditio sine qua non — that produced the harm".
The decision
The Chamber upheld the conviction against Sumimedical. Hospital Santa Margarita de Copacabana had been held 50% liable since the first instance, and since it did not appeal, that liability became final. Hospital General de Medellín, however, was acquitted, as it was found that its care complied with the applicable clinical protocols once the patient arrived at that facility.
What this means for patients and healthcare institutions
For healthcare providers, the ruling reinforces the importance of documenting the assessment of warning signs in pregnant patients, promptly performing the indicated tests, and referring patients without delay to a higher level of care when the clinical picture requires it. For patients and their families, the precedent confirms that obstetric negligence can also be assessed through a gender lens, which affects how the evidence in the case is weighed. If you suspect that a family member was the victim of medical negligence, you can review our guide on what to do if you suspect a case of medical negligence.
Deadlines to file a claim
- Direct reparation action (hospitals, EPS health insurers, or public entities, as occurred in this case): Article 164 of Law 1437 of 2011 (CPACA) establishes that "when direct reparation is sought, the claim must be filed within a term of two (2) years", counted from the day after the harmful event.
- Ordinary civil action (private clinics or physicians): the action is time-barred after ten (10) years, pursuant to Article 2536 of the Civil Code, which sets that term for the statute of limitations on ordinary actions.
It is essential not to confuse these terms: if the claim is against a public entity and the two-year deadline is allowed to lapse in the mistaken belief that ten years are available, the action becomes time-barred with no possibility of recovery.
At Iniciativa Legal Abogados , we support patients and families in Medellín and the rest of Colombia in medical liability cases, from the initial assessment of the case through filing the claim with the appropriate forum. If you suspect that you or a family member were victims of obstetric or medical negligence, contact us for a review of your case.
Sources:
- Council of State, Third Section, Subsection A, ruling of July 9, 2026, case number 05001-23-33-000-2020-03945-01 (docket 72.435), Justice José Roberto Sáchica Méndez: text of the ruling.
- Law 1437 of 2011 (CPACA), Article 164: secretariasenado.gov.co.
- Civil Code, Article 2536: encolombia.com.