In residential complexes and buildings under Colombia's horizontal property regime, the owners' assembly and its administration hold considerable power over the use of common areas and over sanctions against residents. The Constitutional Court, in Judgment T-182 of 2026, set clear limits on that power, in a case that moved public opinion in Bucaramanga and now stands as a relevant precedent for any condominium in the country.
The case resolved a tutela (constitutional protection action) filed by an elderly couple who, for more than 40 years, had lived on the fifth floor of a building with no elevator. Unable to go up and down frequently, they had adapted the building's common rooftop terrace into a support system of their own: they used a basket tied to a rope to receive food and medicine delivered to the building, and also used the terrace to walk and get sunlight. On July 29, 2025, the owners' assembly decided to padlock access to that terrace and, in addition, fined the claimant for not attending the meeting, even though she had previously explained that she could not attend because she was alone caring for her husband.
The tutela was denied at both the first and second instance. On review of the case file (T-11.709.622), the Constitutional Court overturned those rulings and granted the protection sought.
The legal question
The First Review Chamber, with Justice Natalia Ángel Cabo, had to decide whether the owners' assembly had violated the couple's rights to a dignified life, a minimum living standard, health, care and equality by restricting use of the terrace without considering their particular circumstances, and whether it had also violated due process by imposing the fine without weighing the excuse presented.
What the Constitutional Court ruled
The Court concluded that accessibility in buildings under horizontal property does not depend on the goodwill of the majority of owners. According to the official text of the ruling, published on the Constitutional Court's website:
«accessibility is not a generous concession granted by the majority of owners, but a constitutional requirement».
The Chamber explained that the basket-and-terrace system worked as a self-managed support in the face of a physically inaccessible environment (a building with no elevator), and that the condominium could not eliminate it outright without offering equivalent alternatives, without effectively hearing those affected, and without showing that it had exhausted less harmful measures. The Court also noted that a measure that appears neutral —such as closing a common area to all residents equally— can end up being discriminatory when it disproportionately shifts the consequences of an inaccessible environment onto older adults or people with disabilities.
On the fine, the Court found a violation of due process: the sanction was imposed without weighing the claimant's excuse for her absence, in a building that, having been built before Law 675 of 2001, did not even have a horizontal property bylaw brought into line with that law.
The decision
The Court overturned the lower courts' decisions and granted the protection sought. As a result, it ordered that the closure of the terrace be set aside and access to the basket, or an equivalent mechanism, be restored; that a process of reasonable accommodation be carried out with the effective participation of the claimants; and that the building adopt a horizontal property bylaw brought into line with Law 675 of 2001, which it did not have. The Court also bound the municipal administration: it ordered Bucaramanga's mayor's office to activate its institutional services and prepare a diagnostic study on older adults living in buildings without elevators, and urged the Ministry of Health and Social Protection to include the accessibility of the existing housing stock in national aging and old-age public policy.
The legal basis: what Law 675 of 2001 says
The ruling draws on a legal regime that already set limits on the assembly's and the administration's actions —limits that, in practice, many condominiums either overlook or misapply:
- Article 2, paragraph 5, of Law 675 of 2001 enshrines the principle of due process: any sanction imposed by the assembly or the board of administration for failure to meet a non-monetary obligation must observe due process and the right to a defense, to contradict the charge, and to appeal.
- Article 38, paragraph 9, gives the general assembly the power to decide whether sanctions are warranted, but requires that decision to be made «in observance of due process and the right to a defense» set out in the bylaws.
- Article 51, paragraphs 11 and 12, require the administrator to notify sanctions through the means set out in the bylaws and to enforce them only once they have become final.
- On common property, articles 19, 20 and 22 establish that common areas are indivisible and cannot be attached as long as they retain that status, that they may only be removed from common status by an assembly decision backed by 70% of the ownership shares and with municipal authorization, and that common areas not essential to the enjoyment of the private units —such as terraces or patios— may be assigned for the exclusive use of nearby owners.
- Article 46, paragraph 1 requires a qualified 70% majority for any change in the use of a common area, or for decisions that significantly reduce its use and enjoyment.
The Constitutional Court had already placed conditions on part of this regime in Judgment C-318 of 2002 requiring that the right to a defense also be guaranteed to non-owner residents facing sanctions.
What this means for your condominium
Judgment T-182 of 2026 is, first and foremost, a case about accessibility and the protection of older adults, but its practical implications reach much further for any owners' assembly, administrator or owner in Colombia:
- No sanction —including a fine for failing to attend the assembly— is valid unless the person being sanctioned was given a real opportunity to explain themselves or offer a defense before it was imposed.
- Restricting access to common areas, even for legitimate security or maintenance reasons, requires assessing the disproportionate impact on older adults, people with disabilities or other vulnerable residents, and offering reasonable alternatives before resorting to an outright restriction.
- A building built before Law 675 of 2001 is not exempt from complying with it: if it lacks a horizontal property bylaw brought into line with the law, that omission can work against the condominium in litigation.
- Decisions about common property —closing it, changing its use, or assigning it for exclusive use— follow specific majority and procedural rules that cannot be skipped, even with the backing of most of the assembly.
At Iniciativa Legal we advise condominiums, owners and residents alike on reviewing and updating horizontal property bylaws, on internal sanction proceedings, and on tutela actions or ordinary litigation when these limits are not respected. If your condominium is facing a similar situation, or if you believe a decision by the assembly or the administrator violated your rights, you can contact us to evaluate your case.
Sources
- Constitutional Court of Colombia, Judgment T-182 of 2026, Rapporteur Justice Natalia Ángel Cabo, June 18, 2026.
- Law 675 of 2001, establishing Colombia's horizontal property regime.
- Defensoría del Pueblo, «Court protects older adults: reasonable accommodation and accessibility».
- El Espectador, «Bucaramanga: court orders terrace reopened so an elderly couple can receive food and medicine delivered by basket».