The Supreme Court of Justice, Civil, Agrarian and Rural Cassation Chamber, held an EPS (health insurer) and an IPS (healthcare provider) liable for medical malpractice after more than a decade of litigation, and recognized a type of damages that is not always successfully claimed in these cases: the lost earnings of the mother who had to stop working to devote herself entirely to caring for her daughter, who was affected by a medical failure. This was decided in judgment SC072-2025, issued on March 27, 2025, with Justice Octavio Augusto Tejeiro Duque.

The facts: a cardiorespiratory arrest during treatment for pneumonia

The case (docket No. 66001-31-03-004-2013-00141-01) was brought by Valentina and Valeria Morales Zuluaga, Luz Marina Zuluaga Orozco and Orfa Lucina Orozco Prado against Cafesalud E.P.S. (now liquidated) and Pediatras Asociados Ltda., with a third-party claim against La Previsora Compañía de Seguros S.A. According to the facts proven at trial, the child Valentina was treated for fever and malaise and diagnosed with pneumonia complicated by pleural effusion. During a procedure she suffered a cardiorespiratory arrest and was left with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy secondary to resuscitation: quadriplegia, speech and vision impairments, and seizures. Later neuropediatric and neuropsychological evaluations found motor impairments, attention deficit and impulsivity, and a 2008 medical assessment set her loss of working capacity at 70,40 %.

The Fourth Civil Circuit Court of Pereira had denied the claims on February 15, 2016. The Supreme Court, after overturning that decision in judgment SC2348-2021 and ordering additional evidence, has now issued the substitute ruling reviewed here.

The ruling: joint and several liability between the EPS and the IPS

The Court fully reversed the first-instance ruling and held, verbatim:

“Second. To declare that Cafesalud E.P.S. -now liquidated- and Pediatras Asociados Ltda. are civilly and jointly and severally liable for the damages caused to the plaintiffs as a result of the facts giving rise to this proceeding."

The Chamber recalled that the EPS occupies a guarantor position toward its members: “promoting entities assume [the harms] ‘as their own’ and are civilly called upon to compensate the damages suffered by their members, provided those damages can be linked to the omissive or negligent conduct of the organization's medical, care-related or administrative staff.”

The elements of medical liability, according to the Court

The ruling reiterates that medical liability requires the concurrence of four elements: “(I) unlawful conduct; (II) a basis of attribution —subjective or objective—; (III) damage; and (IV) a causal link between the conduct and the damage.” The standard remains that of the proven fault: the patient must show that the medical staff acted with "malpractice, recklessness, negligence or intent," since "as neither medical science nor those who practice it are infallible (...) only errors arising from the physicians' recklessness, malpractice, carelessness or neglect will give rise to the obligation to repair the damages."

The amount of the award

The Court ordered payment of, among other items:

The ruling also ordered that Valentina be guaranteed, without co-payments, the therapies, medications and care she requires for as long as medical science advises, as part of the health damage recognized.

The caregiving mother's lost earnings

The most widely discussed aspect of the ruling is the recognition of the mother's lost earnings. The Court explained that "it is also proven that Luz Marina Zuluaga Orozco, Valentina Morales's mother, suffered lost earnings owing to the impossibility of carrying out income-generating work given the imperative need to care for her daughter." The Chamber specified that the fact that caring for a child is, in principle, a parental duty does not preclude recognizing the economic harm suffered by someone who must give up their productive activity to take on, permanently, the care of a daughter with a disability caused by the negligence of third parties.

What this means for patients, EPS and IPS entities in Colombia

Sources

Call Now Button